What to Look For in an SEO Provider You Can Trust

Yahoo and Bing Search Engines

22 Jun What to Look For in an SEO Provider You Can Trust

Different professionals win their customers’ trust in different ways. For a doctor, say, or a mechanic, there are credentials: certifications and advanced degrees. Things aren’t always so cut-and-dry in the digital marketing world, where many professional roles are multidisciplinary. So how do you know if you can trust an SEO provider? The short answer: results.

There are no official credentials for SEO, so SEO professionals who want to win prospective clients’ trust have to rely on their past work to prove the value of their services. When you start looking more closely at an SEO’s track record, it becomes much easier to separate the wheat from the chaff. Search engine optimization encompasses many marketing activities, and any SEO worth his or her salt will be well-versed in the following:

  • Content marketing – content is the lifeblood of SEO. Without good content, quality SEO results can be kissed goodbye. ‘Content’ includes blog posts, website copy, videos, images, PDFs, infographics, and other assets. All of these media can be optimized for search engines.
  • Search marketing – the sole focus of an SEO is to ensure that your business is visible across search engine results for as many relevant queries searchers use as possible.
  • Consumer behavior – a good SEO will be able to identify important industry trends and search behavior.
  • Advertising – SEO is a form of marketing, and selling your brand to potential customers is the goal. Just because people find your site doesn’t mean that they are going to engage with your business. Creating specific calls-to-action within your content aids this process to create leads and generate sales.
  • Public relations – creating relationships with your potential, current and former customers is essential. SEO accomplishes this by incorporating social media and blogging into campaigns. Reputation management is also at stake here, as online reviews become increasingly important factors in consumers’ purchasing decisions. A good SEO will keep an eye on online reputation, though active reputation management is another discipline entirely.


So how can you tell the difference between a good SEO and a bad SEO?  Unlike doctors and mechanics, SEOs have a more difficult time proving results. Why? Because of tangibility. Optimizing a website does not produce a product, or something that cures your cough. What it does is help people find the information they’re looking for – and trust me, everyone is always looking for something. But that’s the thing – we SEOs can’t provide results in minutes or days. Try months. What’s tangible for what we do are the metrics we provide. We can show you metrics about how much traffic you received during a period of time, where those visitors came from, which pages they visited on your site, and how long they were on your site.

Google Organic Metrics

This data represents a car dealership in Orlando, Florida that sells four brands. Its large metropolitan location, number of brands, and inventory are all factors that affect these metrics. The more brands you sell, the greater the opportunity you have to attract searchers based off of brand recognition. Remember: just because you get a lot of traffic doesn’t mean that traffic is necessarily qualified. You want to make sure you are attracting the users most likely to invest their time and money into your business.

These metrics are important because they indicate areas of opportunity in your SEO campaign, and help diagnose website issues. Metrics are also important in understanding performance over time, to see how your industry and other factors affect your digital marketing results.

SEOs working in any industry understand that their work plays an important part in obtaining new business, but that many factors affect the success of a campaign. The question of ROI causes some businesses to shy away from SEO: they don’t see the value, or aren’t familiar enough with SEO to understand the ROI. Quality SEO work will bring benefit, and offer a solid ROI. Here’s how:

    • Branding – If you’re in a competitive industry and optimize your site for high-volume, competitive keywords, you’ll be more likely to populate in SERPs. More people will visit your site and will understand how your services can help alleviate their problems. Visitor traffic in Analytics will show increases in organic visitors, increases in pageviews per session and an increase in the percentage of new users that visit your site.


Google organic metrics

  • Sales –SEO can lend a hand in creating leads and sales, by driving traffic to your site, which should be optimized with goals and conversions in mind. Your sales can be monitored through advanced website traffic reporting, with Google Analytics, Google Search Console and other third-party services. This data can show you which products your customers are interested in, and where to focus future SEO efforts.
  • Overall traffic increase – having a well-optimized site will help attract more visits to your website, which is just like people walking into your shop. If they visit, it’s likely that you have what they’re looking for, which looks great for your brand and for your sales!

Organic growth over time

This screenshot shows the same car dealership in Orlando, Florida. Organic sessions have increased significantly year over year, and are consistently going up.

It’s important to note that SEO results differ by industry and by business, and depend on how goals are defined. Some metrics may show huge increases, and some small increases. Some metrics may seem negative, but may actually be positive. It is up to the trusty SEO to analyze the data and provide clear, accurate reports.

SEO results aren’t instantaneous; it can take months for optimization to yield traffic increases. SEO is an ongoing process that requires constant tweaking. Search volume for all keywords fluctuates, and user intent also changes. It is important to understand these trends and constantly adapt to search intent to stay on top of your target audience and your competition. Search engine optimization is a worthwhile investment for any business with a website.

In a space where millions of businesses are competing for users’ attention, your brand can’t afford to fall behind.

  • Ethan Hulbert
    Posted at 19:21h, 22 June Reply

    Great article, Stephen! I think two other important factors to look for in an SEO provider are linkbuilding transparency, and attribution with analytics. While obviously building links has changed drastically in the last decade, trusted agencies still do it, but with a much different philosophy, so it’s a good way to weed out inexperienced companies if they talk about the number of links or aren’t willing to show you the sites they put your link on. Good analytics and a direct link from organic discovery down the funnel to conversion and profit are also so important. I know some companies out there literally only report on rankings for keywords, without even thinking about the search volume those phrases get, or the conversions that generating this traffic leads to. All that being said, though, you hit the nail on the head with this article. Great read, thanks for posting!

Post A Comment

13 − three =

Privacy Policy

L2TMedia takes your privacy seriously and is committed to safeguarding your privacy online. This Policy is effective on January 1, 2016.

Because we do gather certain types of information from visitors to our sites, we have developed a privacy statement to help you understand the terms and conditions surrounding the collection and use of that information. This statement discloses the types of information we gather, how it is used, and how you can gain access to and edit any data that we’ve collected about you at any time.

L2TMedia respects the privacy of individuals who visit our website, send us email or participate in features/services we offer online. L2TMedia collects information online primarily to provide our visitors with a more relevant experience on our sites.

By visiting l2tmedia.com or using our products, you agree to the terms of this Privacy Policy. L2TMeida is the sole owner of the information collected on this site. We collect personal information that you submit to us voluntarily. We do not sell or rent personal information to anyone, and will not share it with third parties.

As you use our site or products, certain passive information may also be collected, including your Internet Protocol address, browser type and operating system. We also use cookies, web beacons and navigational data like Uniform Resource Locators (URL) to gather information regarding the date and time of your visit and the solutions and information for which you searched and viewed. This type of information is collected to make our products more useful to you. We collect the domain name and email address (where possible) of visitors to our web page, the email addresses of those who communicate with us via email, aggregate information on what pages consumers access or visit and user-specific information on what pages consumers access or visit.

If you do not want to receive email from us in the future, follow the unsubscribe instructions included in those emails or you can contact us via one of the methods listed below. Persons who supply us with their telephone numbers online will only receive telephone contact from us. If you do not wish to receive telephone calls, please let us know via one of the contact methods below.

From time to time, we may use customer information for new, unanticipated uses not previously disclosed in our privacy notice. If our information practices change at some time in the future, we will contact you before we use your data for these new purposes to notify you of the policy change and to provide you with the ability to opt out of these new uses.

Customers may prevent their information from being used for purposes other than those for which it was originally collected by contacting us via one of the methods listed below. Upon request we provide site visitors with access to contact information (e.g., name, address, phone number) that we maintain about them. Consumers can access and correct this information by contacting us via one of the methods listed below. Upon request we offer visitors the ability to have inaccuracies corrected in their contact information. If you feel that this site is not following its stated information policy, contact us at the methods listed below.

Contact Methods

If you have questions concerning this Privacy Policy, contact us by email to info@l2tmedia.com, calling 888.227.1132 or writing to us at L2TMedia, 1840 Oak Ave., Evanston, IL 60201.